Previous Entry | Next Entry

SG-1 Rewatch: Episode 1.17 "Enigma"

  • Sep. 16th, 2019 at 6:42 PM
theemdash: (SG-1 Sam)
Previous: 1.16 Cor-ai

And so begins Sam's thread of doomed romances.

Narim isn't my favorite of Sam's suitors, but he's not a bad match for her. Sure, he comes on a little strong with his line that he thought she was a space angel, but he's direct with her, telling her—and showing her—how he feels. From there, he lets her decide. I appreciate that he gives her space to figure out her feelings, and that those feelings are unresolved at the end of this episode. What would have happened if Narim had been allowed to stay on Earth without threat from the NID? Would Sam have eventually reciprocated his feelings? It's a nice little what if, and I appreciate that the future appearances with Narim don't forget their initial attraction (even though by then the show was deep into the Relationship Endgame).

But let's talk about the Tollan in general for a moment because this culture is fascinating. This is a culture that values emotions enough that they have a device to record feelings and deem that technology essential enough to carry into a potential suicide mission. They care deeply about how people feel. It is their remorse at interfering with and unintentionally destroying Sureeta that motivates Omoc to appear cold while dealing with the SGC, but obviously he is like the other Tollan and deeply values emotions. I wonder what mental health care looks like on Tollan since they can literally share their feelings. (Anyone know of any fics dealing with that? I'd be interested in reading one!)


A few last notes of significance:
  • The Tollan are the first advanced humans the SGC has come across.

  • If there haven't been animals on Tollan for generations, I would assume they are all vegetarian.

  • This marks the introduction of Colonel Maybourne and the NID.

  • Are there fics about Sam's emotion device? I assume Narim left it with her. (She doesn't give it back on screen, but I didn't count his armbands in later scenes.) Assuming he left it with her, just consider Sam on a lonely night reassuring herself that someone among the stars loves her.

  • Thank you for continuing to use Daniel's civilian status to undermine the megalomaniacal parts of the government.

  • The guest appearance by Lya is fantastic and illustrates the connected nature of SG-1. There's character growth in how SG-1 reacts to advanced technology being withheld and acknowledgement of their growth from Lya. All of this is a build up to "The Fifth Race," and fits so perfectly together that I can't help but think it was planned.



Quote of the Week:
    Hammond: I can't let you do that. We'd all be court martialed.
    Jack: General, I'm about a hair away from not caring. However, Daniel…
    Daniel: I can't be court martialed, sir.


Episode Stats
Planetary Tally: Tollan, aka P3X-7763, the original Tollan homeworld
also mentioned but not visited: Sureeta, the planet whose destruction caused the cataclysm on Tollan
Series Total: 16

In Fashion: the team wears green BDUs on mission; on base, Jack and Daniel wear green BDUs, and Sam and Teal'c switch into green flight suits; during the meeting with Tuplo, Jack and Sam wear dress blues


Next up: 1.18 Solitudes

Comments

princessofgeeks: (Default)
[personal profile] princessofgeeks wrote:
Sep. 17th, 2019 12:30 am (UTC)
I really love this episode, and I believe Sam's awful romances thing began with The First Commandment.

This is one of the eps that is woven into the past and future of the show, but it's also one I think works well as an introduction to the entire show, if someone is looking for an entry point. I suggest it along with Torment of Tantalus.
theemdash: (Daniel Hi)
[personal profile] theemdash wrote:
Sep. 17th, 2019 01:36 am (UTC)
I believe Sam's awful romances thing began with The First Commandment.

Oh, true. I tend to not count him because he doesn't recur (thank God).

I've never thought about "Enigma" as an entry point, but it's a great one. The opening of the episode is just perfect. The alien planet and situation is unusual and then we're immediately thrown a mystery when Omoc says not to help them when they clearly need help!
green_grrl: (SG1_JDWhat)
[personal profile] green_grrl wrote:
Sep. 17th, 2019 04:18 am (UTC)
I have So Many Feelings about Sam and her boyfriends! (Yes, I don't want to count her ex-fiancé. Let’s just say she was working through daddy issues, saw the light, and learned how to find more fulfillment in her career.)

It's not just Narim; all Sam's alien boyfriends do an “instant emotions” thing. I think, technically, it was a way for the writers to create stakes / intimacy within the bounds of an hourlong episode. Martouf has an emotional resonance with the remnants of his soulmate who was psychically joined with her, while Orlin reads her completely when he's an Ascended being and can’t help falling in love with her.

Tiny J/D note for this ep—the scene at the end where Daniel is looking at the gate, radiantly happy, and Jack is looking at Daniel, absolutely smitten.... one of my top ten visual shipping touchpoints for the series.
princessofgeeks: (Default)
[personal profile] princessofgeeks wrote:
Sep. 17th, 2019 11:32 am (UTC)
Yes to all this.

I felt so sorry for Sam by the end of this. All those doomed boyfriends!!!!
jdjunkie: (Default)
[personal profile] jdjunkie wrote:
Sep. 17th, 2019 03:30 pm (UTC)
Tiny J/D note for this ep—the scene at the end where Daniel is looking at the gate, radiantly happy, and Jack is looking at Daniel, absolutely smitten.... one of my top ten visual shipping touchpoints for the series.

THIS. Oh, THIS.

Profile

theemdash: (Default)
[personal profile] theemdash
theemdash

Latest Month

December 2024
S M T W T F S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031    

Tags

Powered by Dreamwidth Studios
Designed by [personal profile] chasethestars