Previous Entry | Next Entry

SG-1 Rewatch: Episode 1.13 "Fire and Water"

  • Aug. 8th, 2019 at 11:11 AM
theemdash: (Daniel Intention)
Previous: 1.12 Bloodlines

Even though Daniel has been declared dead before and all of the human members of SG-1 temporarily bite it in "The Nox," this is the first time in which the team has believed Daniel dead and actually grieved. It's the grieving part that I think is the most interesting because so often in SG-1 in most serial shows characters die and no space is provided for the characters or audience to grieve. But Daniel gets a memorial service in this episode, and his next major death in "Meridian" is followed by an episode that is entirely about the team grieving the loss. (Not to mention adjusting to him being gone is a major theme of Season 6.)

So, what exactly makes Daniel so special? Why spend all this time grieving for him?*

In the confines of this episode, grief is literally a plot point. SG-1 believes Daniel is dead, they have a funeral, but—twist!—Daniel isn't dead. Makes total sense when you're breaking apart the plot of the episode that they would have a memorial service, Jack would eulogize Daniel, and they would be sad about losing their friend. But the grief here shows so much more than them just losing a team member. Kawalsky didn't get this level of on-screen attention from anyone—including Jack. Daniel is special and this episode underlines that for everyone. Daniel is the man who opened the Stargate, the man who (co-)killed Ra, and as Jack says in his eulogy, the conscience of the SGC. If anyone thought Daniel wasn't important, this episode is a flashing neon light of just how important Daniel is to this world.

It all starts with the acting of Richard Dean Anderson, Amanda Tapping, and Chris Judge. When the team first 'gates in and Jack reports "Daniel's dead, sir," the hollowness in his eyes is a knife in the gut. Sam's telling of Daniel's death to Fraiser and during the inquest is equally heart wrenching. This is SG-1 at its finest, emotionally compromised and completely committed to each other.

That commitment may be the reason Daniel is grieved over and over. It's not just that Daniel is important to the existence of the Stargate Program, or that he is often the viewer surrogate, but it's that SG-1 is a family and not acknowledging the loss of one of the core members would feel false. The prolonged "death" of Jack in "Lost City" plays out in similar ways to "Meridian." Each team member gets a moment to say goodbye. There isn't an episode of denouement as in "Revelations"—but, uh, they originally thought the series was ending, so…—but there's enough of the grieving process in "Lost City" to still make it feel significant.

Honestly, there's more to unpack on this topic, but I'm leaving this here for now since that pretty well covers this specific episode.

*I am not griping about the treatment of other prominent deaths here, just talking about what makes Daniel so special.


A few last notes of significance:
  • So many of my notes are about Daniel's eyes and his beautiful face. This is one of the top five episodes for OMG How Are Michael Shanks's Eyes That Blue.

  • How does Daniel translate any cuneiform without his books? Are they sure he doesn't have some Ancient evolved brain powers, too?

  • Have you ever paused to read Daniel's journal? It's hilarious. The line Sam reads is literally stuck in the middle of Daniel musing about, presumably, the Jackal and the Hound. I'm impressed the prop guys bothered to stick it in.

  • Sam volunteers as tribute! For hypnosis.

  • It's so disappointing we never see Nem again. He had cool technology and could have been a link to other, ancient allies.

  • An interesting article on SG-1 Solutions posits that Marduk—the Goa'uld from Kendra's homeworld—may have also been Belus, the Goa'uld who killed Omoroca.


Quote of the Week:
    Jack: Daniel Jackson made this place… happen. As a member of SG-1, he was our voice—our conscience. He was a very courageous man. He was a good man. For those of us lucky enough to have known him, he was also a friend.


Episode Stats
Planetary Tally: Oannes, or as the internet tells us P3X-866 is Nem's planet; also mentioned is P8X-362, a future mission for SG-4
Series Total: 13

In Fashion: there are so many costume changes in this episode: on mission, everyone wears desert camo—Daniel has a flak helmet on the first trip, Sam has one on the second trip; on base Sam and Teal'c take turns wearing the green flight suits, while everyone else is in green BDUs; Jack and Sam are in dress uniform for Daniel's memorial service; their shared hallucination of Daniel returning through the 'gate has him in jungle camo

Brain Washed: Nem messes with Jack, Sam, and Teal'c's memories to make them believe Daniel died in a fire and also planted a desire to never return to P3X-866
Jack: Series Total: 3
Sam: Series Total: 2
Teal’c: Series Total: 1

SG-1 Dies A Lot: through Nem's interference, SG-1 and thus everyone else believes Daniel died on the mission; they even hold a memorial service
Daniel: Series Total: 3

With All Due Respect: Fraiser provides Hammond respect when she insists SG-1 remain on stand down after witnessing Daniel's violent death (jeez, George)
Series Total: 10


Next up: 1.14 Hathor

Comments

princessofgeeks: Shane and Ilya looking at each other in the living room of the cottage (Default)
[personal profile] princessofgeeks wrote:
Aug. 8th, 2019 09:23 pm (UTC)
This is another great SFy stand alone episode. And it was of such interest to the slashers because of how strongly Jack reacted to Daniel's death.

I do think their unsettled-ness might have been due to the fact that it was false memories, and on some level their minds were fighting back.

Also, here's some tech that apparently Teal'c is just as susceptible to as the rest of the team!

It's a great episode.
theemdash: (SG-1 Jack/Daniel The Light)
[personal profile] theemdash wrote:
Aug. 13th, 2019 09:08 pm (UTC)
I absolutely think their minds were fighting back against the false memories. And, yes, it is so easy to see the slash in this episode. Jack's the first to verbally suspect that the memories are false, the first to say that he thinks Daniel is still alive, and the pushiest of them all to reject Daniel's death. I love it. :D

This is easily one of the best episodes of the first season.

... I think I'm saying that more than I should.
green_grrl: (SG1_JDAngst)
[personal profile] green_grrl wrote:
Aug. 9th, 2019 12:05 am (UTC)
Jack breaking Hammond's car window with the hockey stick is just asjklcasdjlkajlkscnadlf
jdjunkie: (approach vector)
[personal profile] jdjunkie wrote:
Aug. 9th, 2019 03:45 pm (UTC)
That moment is in my top one Jack and Daniel moments, to be honest. *g*
green_grrl: (SG1_JDSoDoingIt)
[personal profile] green_grrl wrote:
Aug. 10th, 2019 02:20 am (UTC)
Same!
theemdash: (SG-1 Jack/Daniel Touchies)
[personal profile] theemdash wrote:
Aug. 13th, 2019 09:09 pm (UTC)
Yes, Jack processes emotions physically... it's all in my fic! ;)
jdjunkie: (Default)
[personal profile] jdjunkie wrote:
Aug. 9th, 2019 03:47 pm (UTC)
I love this episode with the fire of a thousand nuns.

I think it's the first one where we really come to understand exactly how much Daniel means to the team and the program.

He matters. And we LOVE him. *g*
theemdash: (Daniel Hi)
[personal profile] theemdash wrote:
Aug. 13th, 2019 09:11 pm (UTC)
He matters SO. MUCH. One of the fics I read (and God help me being able to remember which one because there were a LOT for this episode) has all the officers saluting Daniel after his return from the dead and he's all confused about it until someone explains it and it's adorable. I love him.
oldtoadwoman: Sam Winchester, Supernatural 14x17 (stargate)
[personal profile] oldtoadwoman wrote:
Aug. 11th, 2019 12:38 pm (UTC)
Fire and Water
Oh, man, yes, his eyes are so pretty. This was definitely one of those episodes where I don't think I even processed the plot at all because I was distracted by Daniel being pretty.

I was tickled that Nem's gills wiggled when he was being all intense. Nice detail.

In hindsight, I think Daniel's apartment was too nice. I mentally envision Daniel's living space would look exactly like his office with stacks of things everywhere. The plot used the fish tank for the bubble-triggered flashback, but I don't feel like Daniel would have put the effort into setting up a fish tank. I just can't picture Daniel making the time to go to the pet store to pick out fish, so my headcanon is that the fish tank belonged to the previous tenant who didn't want to move it and offered to leave it behind and Daniel was just like, "Huh? Oh, yeah, sure. Whatever."

badfalcon: (Jack Daniel Hug)
[personal profile] badfalcon wrote:
Feb. 22nd, 2020 02:46 pm (UTC)
It doesn't matter how many times I watch this episode, I find myself grieving along with the rest of the team. From Jack's "Daniel's dead, Sir" which always hits me like a sucker punch, and I start crying during the memorial. Even though I know Daniel isn't dead, because it's so real to Jack and Sam and Teal'c, it's real to me as well *sniffles*
theemdash: (SG-1 Jack & Daniel The Light)
[personal profile] theemdash wrote:
Feb. 22nd, 2020 03:26 pm (UTC)
It is such a good episode. The construction, structure, the acting—oh yeah, it hits you right in the feels.

Profile

theemdash: (Default)
[personal profile] theemdash
theemdash

Latest Month

December 2024
S M T W T F S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031    

Tags

Powered by Dreamwidth Studios
Designed by [personal profile] chasethestars